How to Increase the Resale Value of a Craftsman Bungalow Home

Craftsman bungalow homes are renowned for their classic architecture, intricate woodwork, and welcoming front porches, making them highly desirable to buyers who appreciate character and craftsmanship. However, when it comes to selling, increasing the resale value of a Craftsman home is not just about modernizing the property – it’s about preserving its defining features while updating spaces and systems to meet the expectations of modern buyers.

Whether you’re selling a Craftsman bungalow in Seattle, WA, or renovating a character-filled home in Pasadena, CA, knowing which improvements to prioritize can make a significant difference. In this Redfin guide, we’ll delve into expert-recommended ways to enhance a Craftsman bungalow while staying true to its architectural roots, from strategic renovations to simple updates that breathe new life into the home.

In this article:
What is a Craftsman bungalow-style home?
Preserve the home’s original architecture and character
Address major systems before cosmetic upgrades
Upgrade windows and doors without sacrificing character
Improve energy efficiency
Keep the Craftsman’s traditional layout when possible
Boost curb appeal with Craftsman-appropriate colors and materials
Use paint and staging to create a fresh, inviting interior
How to increase the resale value of a Craftsman bungalow home: Final thoughts

What is a Craftsman bungalow-style home?

A Craftsman bungalow is a style of early 20th-century home known for its focus on craftsmanship, natural materials, and functional design. Stemming from the broader American Craftsman movement, which arose in opposition to the ornate Victorian architecture of the late 19th century, Craftsman homes emphasize simple forms, handcrafted details, and a strong connection to nature. While these homes vary in size and layout, bungalows typically feature one or one-and-a-half stories, low-profile design, and a welcoming front porch.

Key features of a Craftsman bungalow include:

Low-pitched roof: Broad, gently sloping roofs with wide, overhanging eaves and exposed rafters.

Front porch: Prominent covered porch supported by tapered columns.

Natural materials: Wood, stone, brick, and other natural materials for a warm, handcrafted look.

Exposed beams and rafters: Structural elements intentionally visible and integrated into the design.

Built-in features: Built-in bookcases, cabinetry, benches, and other woodwork for character and functionality.

Distinctive windows: Grouped or divided-light windows to complement the home’s horizontal proportions.

Open but defined living spaces: Distinct living, dining, and family areas while maintaining some separation.

Emphasis on craftsmanship: Detailed woodwork, custom millwork, and carefully crafted architectural elements.

>>Read more: Buying a Historic Home: What to Know Before You Buy and How to Preserve It

Preserve the home’s original architecture and character

One of the key advantages of a Craftsman bungalow is its unique architectural character, so it’s crucial to prioritize preserving original details when making improvements.

“When remodeling a Craftsman bungalow, it is essential to maintain the home’s architectural style,” advises Jeffrey Nott at Nott & Associates. “Period features like front porches and wood beams provide the home with comfort and charm, evoking a simpler era.”

When updates are necessary, the goal should be to complement the existing architecture rather than overshadowing it. Thoughtful restoration can retain the features that make a Craftsman bungalow special while allowing homeowners to enhance comfort, functionality, and overall appeal for today’s buyers.

>>Check out: What Is My Home Worth?

Address major systems before cosmetic upgrades

Older homes may have outdated or deteriorating components that could be uncovered during a buyer’s inspection, potentially leading to costly negotiations or reducing the property’s appeal. Prioritizing these projects can instill greater confidence in buyers and ensure that cosmetic enhancements add value rather than masking underlying issues.

“You don’t have to maintain everything in its original state, but authenticity is crucial. Craftsman buyers value materials over features,” notes Oren Amir at Go Home Builders. “Invest in updates to electrical, plumbing, foundation bolting, and seismic retrofitting – these are the issues that can derail a deal during inspection and are challenging to rectify post-listing.”

Consider focusing on:

Electrical: Evaluate and update outdated wiring, service panels, or other electrical components as needed.

Plumbing: Address aging pipes, leaks, deteriorated drains, and other plumbing issues before listing.

Foundation: Inspect for structural problems and complete necessary repairs or reinforcement.

Seismic retrofits: In earthquake-prone regions, consider foundation bolting and other seismic enhancements to enhance safety and appeal to buyers.

Upgrade windows and doors without sacrificing character

Windows and doors play a significant role in a Craftsman bungalow’s curb appeal, so replacing them offers an opportunity to enhance performance without compromising architectural character. If original windows are beyond repair, opt for replacements that mirror the home’s existing proportions, materials, and divided-light patterns rather than opting for generic modern styles.

“If the windows are in poor condition, replace them with wood in the same divided-lite pattern, not vinyl,” advises Oren Amir. “This principle applies to the kitchen as well: quartz countertops with bold veining and cabinets featuring faux wood grain can prematurely date a house more than an outdated kitchen ever could.”

When selecting replacement windows and doors, consider:

Match the existing window pattern: Replicate the home’s original divided-light or muntin pattern whenever feasible.

Choose complementary materials: Opt for wood or wood-clad options to preserve the warmth and character associated with Craftsman architecture.

Preserve distinctive proportions: Pay attention to the size, shape, trim, and placement of existing windows and doors.

Maintain authenticity with the front door: If the original door needs replacement, consider a wood-paneled design with glazing or other details that complement the home’s existing windows.

Improve energy efficiency

Enhancing energy efficiency can make a Craftsman bungalow more comfortable and attractive to buyers while potentially reducing ongoing utility costs. Since these homes were typically constructed over a century ago, updates such as insulation, air sealing, and efficient HVAC systems can enhance performance without necessitating a compromise on the architectural details that define the property.

“To boost the resale value of a Craftsman bungalow, focus on improving energy efficiency with windows and doors that match the style, insulation, and efficient HVAC systems,” recommends Cesar Espejo at Pasadena Craftsman. “Address major systems like outdated plumbing, deteriorated cast-iron drains, knob-and-tube wiring, and the electrical service panel.”

Consider energy-efficient enhancements such as:

Insulation: Add or upgrade insulation in areas like the attic, walls, or crawl space where appropriate.

Efficient HVAC: Replace outdated heating and cooling systems with a more efficient setup sized correctly for the home.

Air sealing: Address drafts and air leaks around windows, doors, and other openings to enhance comfort and efficiency.

Energy-efficient upgrades: Consider modern improvements that blend visually with the home’s Craftsman architecture.

Keep the Craftsman’s traditional layout when possible

When updating a Craftsman bungalow, avoid completely altering the floor plan just to achieve a more modern feel. Traditional Craftsman layouts were designed to create a seamless flow between living spaces while maintaining distinct room purposes, and features like defined living and dining areas contribute to the home’s character.

“Craftsman homes may lack the spacious kitchens, baths, and closets of newer properties, but don’t rush into a modern open-concept layout,” advises Jeffrey Nott. “Maintain the formality of the Craftsman home with separate living, dining, and family areas. The objective is to enhance the home without sacrificing the classic style and charm that makes a Craftsman home exceptional.”

Instead of tearing down walls to create a large open space, consider ways to improve functionality while preserving the existing layout:

Maintain distinct living areas: Keep living, dining, and family rooms separate if the original floor plan allows.

Enhance flow: Use furniture placement, lighting, and strategic openings to create connectivity between rooms while maintaining their individual identities.

Update for modern needs: Add storage, improve kitchen functionality, or renovate bathrooms without drastically altering the home’s footprint.

Preserve architectural details: Retain features like built-ins, columns, wood trim, and room openings that define the Craftsman style.

Boost curb appeal with Craftsman-appropriate colors and materials

The exterior of a Craftsman bungalow is a significant selling point, so thoughtful improvements to curb appeal can create a lasting first impression without compromising the home’s character.

“For the exterior, opt for a Craftsman three-color scheme that highlights the windows, porch, and woodwork,” suggests Jeffrey Nott.

When updating the exterior, consider:

Choose a complementary color palette: Use two or three coordinated paint colors to distinguish the main body, trim, and accent features.

Accentuate architectural details: Use contrasting yet complementary colors on windows, porch columns, trim, and woodwork to make these features pop.

Renew the front porch: Repair any worn wood, railings, or columns and maintain the porch’s welcoming appearance, as it’s often a standout feature.

Don’t overlook the front door: A carefully selected stain or accent color can draw attention to the entrance while harmonizing with the rest of the exterior.

Use paint and staging to create a fresh, inviting interior

A fresh coat of paint and thoughtful staging can breathe new life into a Craftsman bungalow, making it brighter, more welcoming, and move-in ready without the need for major renovations. The aim is to refresh the interior without losing its unique character.

“To enhance the resale value of a Craftsman bungalow, the focus is on honoring its historical character while giving it a fresh, inviting feel – as home decor, much like fashion, evolves over time,” say Ted Clark & Heather Lillard. “Light, warm paint colors can brighten the interiors, while strategic staging can soften the wood accents that define Craftsman architecture. The result is a contemporary ambiance without compromising the home’s original charm.”

When preparing the interior for sale, consider:

Work with existing wood accents: Instead of painting over original woodwork, use furnishings, textiles, and wall colors that complement or balance its visual impact.

Highlight built-ins and architectural details: Arrange furniture and decor to showcase original cabinetry, beams, fireplaces, trim, and other character-rich elements.

Ensure inviting staging: Utilize appropriately sized furniture and simple decor to help buyers envision living in the space without feeling cramped.

Establish a cohesive look: Choose a consistent color palette throughout the home to create a sense of connection while preserving individual character in each room.